Porpoising questions... |
Post Reply |
Author | |
ken@ckbd.com
Newbie Joined: May-31-2004 Location: United States Status: Offline Points: 17 |
Post Options
Thanks(0)
Posted: May-31-2004 at 1:02am |
I have a 68 mustang, dad bought it new. It's always porpoised above 3800 rpm. WOT was never an option unless there were 3 people in the front seat and nobody else on board. Since a recent rebuild with engine change (351) and prop change (12x14 cupped), the porpoising starts at the usual 3800, but then at WOT the hull seems to nose-down & 'stick' to the water. Steering becomes almost unresponsive until you back off on the throttle and push the wheel hard either left or right - the hull 'pops' loose and you're in control of the steering again. What gives???
|
|
68 Mustang
|
|
Robert
Newbie Joined: April-24-2004 Location: United States Status: Offline Points: 4 |
Post Options
Thanks(0)
|
I have a pair of about 2" x 4.5" aluminum wedges which were on rear corners of the 1969 Ski Tique I bought several years ago. This hull when loaded with one driver and one observer would smoothly run right up to 42 MPH. If there were as little as one rear passenger, without these wedges this hull would porpoise in the 20+ MPH range. SE Correct Craft said I must remove the wedges if the hull was to keep the Approved Water Ski decal. I sold the boat, without wedges, to a ski enthusist who wanted to be legal. I'll be happy to send the wedges to you for free to see if they will eliminate your porpoise. veasybottom@aol.com
|
|
Robert
|
|
ken@ckbd.com
Newbie Joined: May-31-2004 Location: United States Status: Offline Points: 17 |
Post Options
Thanks(0)
|
Robert,
I tried to email you at veasybottom@aol.com and the address is 'undeliverable'. Is it spelled correctly? I appreciate the offer - it's very kind and generous. I have some questions before I accept: I don't like the idea of making hull penetrations for the sake of experimentation, so I would like to know a little more. - How and where were these wedges mounted? - Were these designed for this purpose or are the 'homemade'? - How did they impact your wake pattern? My Mustang will porpoise at 25 or 30 mph if I have 2 or 3 passengers in the rear. It's frustrating because we often load up the family or friends for a cruise around the lake and I can't go fast, but of course everybody wants to! It's got a 351 in it now and it sure can move when you want it to, but there is a lot of top-end that I can't use. Hole-shots are great though. |
|
68 Mustang
|
|
Jamie
Newbie Joined: May-27-2004 Location: United States Status: Offline Points: 13 |
Post Options
Thanks(0)
|
I have a 68 Ski Nautique with a similar problem - when you stated that the steering on your Mustang is unresponsive, then 'pops' into a track again, this is what happens to our boat, BUT ONLY ON RIGHT TURNS!
When we are at any planing speed and attempt to recover from a right hand turn, the boat is very slow to comeback, then 'pops', almost violently into a straight track again, though no porpoising is ever a problem. I would appreciate some insight. Thanks! |
|
1968 SN 1548
|
|
ken@ckbd.com
Newbie Joined: May-31-2004 Location: United States Status: Offline Points: 17 |
Post Options
Thanks(0)
|
Jamie,
I'll be in Nashua this weekend for a wedding. Where is your boat located in relation? |
|
68 Mustang
|
|
kenny g
Senior Member Joined: December-13-2003 Location: United States Status: Offline Points: 318 |
Post Options
Thanks(0)
|
hey jamie,you say the 68 nautique only dose this on right turns.is this a RH rotation engine ?
this porpoising thing has really sparked my interest.been thinkin about this a couple days now and everything keeps coming back to one thing.WEIGHT.or improper weight distribution. why ? alot of us that experience this problem own older boats.over time,water enters the hull cavity around the exaust tubes at the transom.CC realized this would happen so they installed a bulkhead between the primary & secondary stringer just in front of the exaust hose were it bends up to the motor.do you guys realize how much weight 7'x10" of saturated flotation foam weighs ? and how this could effect the handling of our classic beautys. this may not be the answer but it sure is something to think about. |
|
kenny g
|
|
Jamie
Newbie Joined: May-27-2004 Location: United States Status: Offline Points: 13 |
Post Options
Thanks(0)
|
Ken, our boat is on Merrymeeting Lake in New Durham, NH.
Kenny, well, as to the water logged foam situation, I replaced the wet exhaust tubes and found very little in the way of saturated foam. There was a small amount of water evident, but only the very bottom half inch of foam. I did some checking under the seats and found no moisture under there to warrant such an odd handling situation. Thing is, why would the boat just do this on right hand turns? Odd... |
|
1968 SN 1548
|
|
Robert
Newbie Joined: April-24-2004 Location: United States Status: Offline Points: 4 |
Post Options
Thanks(0)
|
Sorry Ken: It is rveasybottom@aol.com. They use small screws sealed with a caulking compound.
|
|
Robert
|
|
yellowdog
Senior Member Joined: December-21-2003 Location: United States Status: Offline Points: 135 |
Post Options
Thanks(0)
|
Just throwing this out, no facts or science offered!
Is it possible that CC spent so much effort on the hull design of these early models to make them track well through a slalom course that they sacrificed (or lost) some steerage? -OR- Is it possible that the repowering with the 351 is pushing so much water past the rudder that it seems 'frozen' until you back off? Are the rudders for a 302 and 351 boat the same size? The added hp may have something to do with the porpoise issue? Like I said, no science here, just thoughts. |
|
Caretaker of the wife's '78 Ski Nautique
|
|
kenny g
Senior Member Joined: December-13-2003 Location: United States Status: Offline Points: 318 |
Post Options
Thanks(0)
|
steering control is 1 issue,porpoising,another.JAMIE has a steering issue...this is interesting.
BLOWOUT.occurs when the ratio of air to water around the propeller gets so high that the prop is no longer grabbing water,but is trying to propel itself through air[or a relative vacuum]this causes the prop to lose "bite",and then a chain of events occurs, from a loose steering feeling,to a VICIOUS TURN TO THE RIGHT [depending on engine rotation]the speed at which this occurs varies with hull,gear case and prop design.it sounds to me like this happens to jamie's boat,the prop loses bite for a time and then it grabs ,jerking the boat back on track. just my 2&1/2cents where the hell is that button on this thing ! |
|
kenny g
|
|
ken@ckbd.com
Newbie Joined: May-31-2004 Location: United States Status: Offline Points: 17 |
Post Options
Thanks(0)
|
YellowDog: I'm pretty sure that part of my problem is because the boat is overpowered. I never thought that I would admit that ANY vehicle could be OVER-powered; never enough horsepower, you know. But this might be the case with my Mustang. The prop (12x14) is pushing a lot more water than before when it originally had a 12x12 prop. I was going to throw the 12x12 back on and experiment a little, but I'm afraid of over-reving.
KennyG: It sounds like Jamie and I are having the same 'hull sticking' issue. The boat will be porpoising and then suddenly 'stick' to the water. Bouncing of course stops and the boat goes like hell. But it does have a right-hand pull (I would never let go of the wheel at this point because of the intense pressure I feel on the rudder). As I back off the throttle, the boat pulls down even harder until the 'pop' occurs and the boat returns to a normal plain. It's not a comforting feeling at all when it's sticking. I think I'll try Roberts wedges and see what happens. |
|
68 Mustang
|
|
kenny g
Senior Member Joined: December-13-2003 Location: United States Status: Offline Points: 318 |
Post Options
Thanks(0)
|
OK ! i found what we need guys.go to general discussion,page 7 .click on reids rides,i think this will answer alot of questions.
|
|
kenny g
|
|
ken@ckbd.com
Newbie Joined: May-31-2004 Location: United States Status: Offline Points: 17 |
Post Options
Thanks(0)
|
Kenny G: The 'reids rides' discussion started someplace else...what did we miss?
What is "rake"? They mentioned it a few times when talking about their props. None the less, what I'm getting out of all this is: by oversizing the powerplant and screwing with prop sizes, we are pushing these hulls beyond their design capability. These boats were not designed to go much over 40 mph and aren't supposed to be speed-boats. By trying to make them such, we are only looking for trouble. With that said, I guess it's time to admit to myself that my little Mustang will never be the same as having one of Reggie Fountains 47' Lightnings. Woe is me. |
|
68 Mustang
|
|
kenny g
Senior Member Joined: December-13-2003 Location: United States Status: Offline Points: 318 |
Post Options
Thanks(0)
|
rake is the longitudinal angle of the prop blades.usually,higher-rake propellers provide more bow lift and better holding power.
rake and pitch are not always related. i have the same hull you have and run a 13x13 thats what it was designed to have.i'm sure the 318 has a little more HP since the rebuild.[bigger pistons,ect]i don't beleave that has anything to do with it as i understand HP dose not become the greater facter until you past the 5250 rpm range.the barracuda handles just fine at 45-48 mph and i expect to hit the 50mph mark since i removed 400 to 500 lbs of saturated flotation foam.i do have a 13x14 for a spare but never had a reason to try it.if i wanna go past the 50 mark i dont wanna do it in the cc.i'll buy that 21'eliminator daytona pickle fork gas drinkin beauty. sandy thinks i'm nuts anyway ! i can prove it ! i did change the engine rotation during the rebuild,but the hull dosen't know that.steering control is the same as b4. |
|
kenny g
|
|
reidp
Platinum Member Joined: December-06-2003 Location: Mooresville, NC Status: Offline Points: 1804 |
Post Options
Thanks(0)
|
I'm jumpin in! Most all of what Ken is experiencing with his 68 Mustang I've been thru for 5+ years and still go thru with my 70 Mustang (Diaries, light blue 1970). I've come to sadly accept and agree with Ken that it's the result of pushing this hull faster than it was designed to go in its current bottom configuration. This hull has significant hook designed in it to keep the nose down and attempt to limit the porpoising. The term Ken used for the hull to "stick", I also know too well. I've seen this in two of our boats and yet never felt it in any other boats below +/- 50mph. You throttle up and hit a certain higher speed and the forward hull portion instantly, not gradually, sucks down to the water surface, and you immediately feel the extra drag. Decelerating in my 70 from higher speeds with a boat load can be uncomfortable also with a tendancy to pull and lean to starboard. My 73 Mustang, while stock and not nearly as fast, still on occasion will nicely and gently reach top speed only to have the nose instantly drop down slightly and actually lose a mph and 100 rpm and for several years I thought I had a slight high rpm engine problem until finally realizing what it was doing. With a bit or weight in the back seat it doesn't do it. And the 73 doesn't exhibit any of the unusual handling characteristics of the 70, but they are two different hull designs. Ken, if you'd give me a call sometime at 704-451-5080 I'd like to hear more about your boat and how it handles. Thanks.
|
|
kenny g
Senior Member Joined: December-13-2003 Location: United States Status: Offline Points: 318 |
Post Options
Thanks(0)
|
reid,it sounds like adding wedges or trim tabs or whatever you call em would cause the nose to dig in even more at higher speeds.like adding more hook to the hull design. but could only help on deceleration.
dose that make any sense or do i have it backwords ? i never did pay much attention to the ol airguide speedo.i think it's a lier past 44 or so,the needle just bounces too much.to me it's more important to monitor the other stuff,bikinis,thongs,beer level in the cooler. |
|
kenny g
|
|
ken@ckbd.com
Newbie Joined: May-31-2004 Location: United States Status: Offline Points: 17 |
Post Options
Thanks(0)
|
Kenny G: I gotta' party with you!
Old Correct Craft = chick magnet regarding the wedges: I think you're right. THey will provide more hook and only intensify my high-speed hook problem. However, if I want the boat to cruise around the lake nicely at 35 mph with 2 or 3 people in the back seat, then I think I have to add more hook (via the wedges) to keep the boat from bouncing. Do I have it right or do I have it backwards? |
|
68 Mustang
|
|
tstafford
Groupie Joined: March-15-2004 Location: United States Status: Offline Points: 81 |
Post Options
Thanks(0)
|
Wow!
With the number of hits on this thread it seems to be a common problem. My mustang does this as well. I cant wait to see the changes if any after removeing lots of saturated foam. When new did these boats ever performe this way? |
|
Trevor 1968 Mustang
|
|
jameski
Senior Member Joined: May-18-2004 Location: United States Status: Offline Points: 368 |
Post Options
Thanks(0)
|
When I bought my boat last year it had some steering problems similar to those mentioned. I found and fixed all of the "play" in the steering linkages and the problem disappeared. Now my boat does ~50mph and handles PERFECTLY!
|
|
Fisherman
Newbie Joined: September-10-2005 Location: United States Status: Offline Points: 24 |
Post Options
Thanks(0)
|
I just acquired a '78 SN and have expeienced the same issues on porpoising at around 34 MPH. It actually began doing it at a lower speed (32) when I removed the 70lbs that the PO had in the rear seat.
When everyone is talking about removing soaked foam I assume you have to remove the floor to do this? Also does anyone have any ideas on leaking from the bow at idle speed? The PO stated that this is due to the connection between hull and deck. Doe sthis make sense? |
|
Central Oregon
'79 Ski Nautique '84 & '85 MBZ Diesels '79 Apollo 3000DB It doesn't need to run bad or look bad just because it's old! |
|
Jerry
Guest |
Post Options
Thanks(0)
|
My 77 leaked at the bow eye during idle speeds. I removed the eye and reinstalled with plenty of 3m dealent. Hasne leaked since.
|
|
ken@ckbd.com
Guest |
Post Options
Thanks(0)
|
I was fortunate enough to have someone give me a set of aluminum wedges (see earlier postings above) and these made a big change in the performance of my hull. I'm a little slower at top end, but my boat will NOT porpoise at all. I love it, and so does my wife!
Replacing foam is not a weekend project...it's a big job. I completely gutted my boat, removed everything. Cut out all the wood and replaced it, new foam, new exhaust tubes...everything. The best tools I found for removing foam were a gasket scraper (auto parts store) and a regular old hand saw. Most of it came out in big chunks, even the wet stuff. As for your leak; I would get a friend to walk around the bow with one of those halogen spot lights while you climb up under the dash. If it's the seam where the bow and deck meet, you can fix that with caulk or fiberglass. It's probably the bow eye though, like Jerry suggested. |
|
Fisherman
Guest |
Post Options
Thanks(0)
|
I'm thinking the bow eye also as it appears to be damp around the base of it when I look up in there wiht a flashlight. Odd thing though is like this weekend I idled around for maybe an hour or so total and never got any moisture at all in the boat.
I'll pull it this winter and recaulk it. Thanks |
|
Post Reply | |
Tweet
|
Forum Jump | Forum Permissions You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot create polls in this forum You cannot vote in polls in this forum |